Leonardo free to build new TH-119 Navy trainer as GAO denies Airbus protest
By Dan Parsons | May 14, 2020
Estimated reading time 3 minutes, 45 seconds.
Leonardo Helicopters is cleared to fire up its TH-119 U.S. Navy trainer production line now that the U.S. government has denied a protest by Airbus Helicopters of the potential $648 million contract.
The Navy in January chose Leonardo’s TH-119, based on the commercial AW119, over the Airbus H135 and Bell 407GXi to replace the aging TH-57 Sea Rangers on which all Navy, U.S. Marine Corps, and U.S. Coast Guard rotorcraft pilots are trained.
Airbus filed a protest with the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) on Feb. 3, arguing that its twin-engine H135 was not properly considered to replace the aging TH-57 Sea Ranger.
Bell, which built the legacy TH-57 Sea Ranger, did not protest Leonardo’s win.
The protest halted TH-119 production at Leonardo’s Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, plant until GAO ruled on the protest. Though a decision was not due until June 22, GAO denied the protest on May 12, freeing Leonardo to continue building the single-engine helicopters.
“On Tuesday, the U.S. Government Accountability Office denied the protest of the Navy’s contract award of the Advanced Helicopter Training System (AHTS) program to Leonardo,” a Leonardo spokesperson said in a statement. “As a result, Leonardo has immediately resumed work on AHTS in Philadelphia, readying the next generation of U.S. Naval Aviators.”
Article Continues Below
An initial $176.5 million outlay awarded to Leonardo in January covers the first 32 aircraft plus spare parts, support equipment, flyaway kits, hoists, sling loads, maintenance and instructional data, and training for maintenance personnel.
The total contract value is $648.1 million for the procurement of 130 TH-73As to replace the TH-57 fleet. Helicopter deliveries are scheduled to begin in calendar year 2020 and continue through calendar year 2024.
Few details of GAO’s reasoning for the denial are available. The protest is covered by a protective order, meaning the parties have to agree on a redacted version of the decision before it is publicly released.
Airbus stood out in the competition for offering the twin-engine H135, which is more expensive upfront and more costly to operate. The company made the argument that the H135 was more representative of the advanced fleet aircraft pilots would fly after graduation from flight training, like the twin-engine Sikorsky MH-60 and CH-53 helicopters, Bell AH-1Z Viper and UH-1Y Venom, and the Bell-Boeing V-22 Osprey.
“Because it was clear that certain technical errors had affected the Navy’s assessment of our offering, we felt an obligation to our U.S. workforce and to the Navy to raise the concerns articulated in our protest,” an Airbus Helicopters spokesperson told Vertical in an email. “We appreciate GAO evaluating our protest, and regret that nonetheless the Navy will not be purchasing the aircraft that was objectively the most affordable, most capable and most thoroughly proven offering. Airbus helicopters – and the H135 in particular — remain the most popular military training helicopter in the world for good reason, with more than 350 aircraft training pilots for the U.S. Military and our closest allies.”